When it comes to choosing the perfect pair of boat shoes, the debate between docksiders vs topsiders has been raging on for decades. Which one is better? Well, the answer is not as simple as it may seem. While docksiders offer a classic and rugged look, topsiders provide a more sleek and modern style. Both options have their own unique features and benefits, making the decision a matter of personal preference and individual needs. In this article, we will delve into the key differences between docksiders and topsiders, helping you make an informed choice that suits your style and lifestyle. Let’s dive right in!
Docksiders vs Topsiders
Whether you’re a fashion enthusiast or simply looking for a comfortable and stylish shoe option, you’ve likely come across the terms “docksiders” and “topsiders.” These two popular styles of footwear have their own unique features and are often associated with different lifestyles and activities. In this article, we will explore the key differences between docksiders and topsiders, helping you make an informed decision when choosing your next pair of shoes.
1. Origins and History
Docksiders
Docksiders, also known as boat shoes, first emerged in the early 20th century as a functional footwear choice for sailors and boaters. Paul Sperry, a sailor and inventor, developed the first dockside shoe with a rubber sole that provided excellent traction on wet boat decks. This original design became the foundation for the modern docksider.
Topsiders
On the other hand, topsiders gained popularity a little later. The term “topsiders” was coined by the Sperry brand, which introduced their iconic Topsider boat shoe in 1935. While topsiders share a similar design with docksiders, they are a specific type of boat shoe produced by the Sperry company.
2. Design and Construction
Docksiders
Docksiders are known for their distinctive moccasin construction. They typically feature a leather upper, a non-marking rubber sole with siping (fine slits for improved traction), and lacing details around the sides. The hand-sewn construction ensures durability and flexibility, making docksiders an excellent choice for casual wear.
Topsiders
Topsiders, as a subset of boat shoes, share many design elements with docksiders. They feature a leather upper, a rubber sole with siping, and lacing details. However, Sperry topsiders often incorporate additional design elements such as contrasting colors, decorative stitching, and the signature Sperry logo on the side.
3. Functionality
Docksiders
Docksiders were specifically designed for use on boat decks. The siped rubber sole provides impressive traction on wet surfaces, preventing slips and falls. The non-marking sole also ensures that docksiders won’t leave scuff marks or damage boat finishes. While docksiders are perfect for boating and other water activities, they have also become a popular choice for everyday casual wear.
Topsiders
Topsiders, being a type of boat shoe, offer similar functionality to docksiders. They provide excellent traction, thanks to the siped rubber sole. Topsiders are great for boating and water-based activities, but they have also evolved into a stylish option for everyday fashion, both on and off the boat.
4. Style and Versatility
Docksiders
Docksiders have a timeless and classic look that exudes a sense of casual sophistication. They are available in a range of colors and materials, including traditional brown leather and more contemporary options like suede and canvas. Docksiders can be easily dressed up or down depending on the occasion, making them a versatile choice for various outfits.
Topsiders
Topsiders, with their association to the Sperry brand, have become a fashion statement in their own right. They offer a wide variety of styles and colors, allowing individuals to express their personal style. Topsiders can effortlessly complement both casual and more polished looks, making them a go-to option for many fashion-forward individuals.
5. Comfort and Fit
Docksiders
Docksiders are renowned for their exceptional comfort. The hand-sewn construction and soft leather uppers conform to the shape of your feet over time, providing a customized fit. Additionally, docksiders typically feature a cushioned insole for added support, ensuring all-day comfort.
Topsiders
Topsiders, like docksiders, prioritize comfort. They are designed with cushioned insoles and a supportive structure to ensure a comfortable fit even during extended periods of wear. Topsiders also feature functional lacing that allows for easy adjustment and a snug fit.
6. Price Range
Docksiders
The price range for docksiders can vary depending on factors such as brand, material, and craftsmanship. However, you can typically find a pair of high-quality docksiders in the range of $80 to $150.
Topsiders
Topsiders, being a specific boat shoe brand, are available at a range of price points. Depending on the style and material, you can expect to pay between $70 and $150 for a pair of Sperry topsiders.
7. Maintenance and Care
Docksiders
Maintaining and caring for docksiders is relatively straightforward. Regularly clean the leather uppers with a damp cloth, remove any stains as soon as possible, and apply a leather conditioner to keep the material supple and moisturized. Avoid submerging docksiders in water or exposing them to extreme heat.
Topsiders
Topsiders require similar care to docksiders due to their shared leather construction. Cleaning and conditioning the leather regularly will help maintain the shoes’ appearance and prolong their lifespan. It’s important to follow the specific care instructions provided by the manufacturer to ensure optimal maintenance.
8. Popular Brands
Docksiders
Some popular docksider brands include:
– Sperry
– Sebago
– Timberland
– Dockers
– Cole Haan
Topsiders
The Sperry brand is synonymous with topsiders. They offer a wide range of styles and designs under the topsider category. Other popular topsider brands include:
– Polo Ralph Lauren
– Eastland
– Merrell
– Nautica
9. Deciding Factors
When deciding between docksiders and topsiders, there are a few factors to consider:
– Intended Use: If you plan to primarily use the shoes for boating or water-related activities, both docksiders and topsiders would be suitable options. If fashion is your main consideration, topsiders offer a wider range of styles and designs.
– Budget: Determine your budget and compare prices from different brands to find a suitable option within your price range.
– Comfort: Both docksiders and topsiders prioritize comfort, but it’s always recommended to try them on and see which one feels better on your feet.
– Personal Style: Consider your personal style preferences and the overall aesthetic you want to achieve. Docksiders lean towards a classic look, while topsiders offer more contemporary and fashionable options.
10. Conclusion
In conclusion, docksiders and topsiders are both excellent choices when it comes to boat shoes. Whether you prioritize functionality, style, or comfort, both styles offer a range of options to suit your needs. Consider the factors mentioned in this article, try on different brands, and select the shoe that best aligns with your preferences. Remember, the ultimate goal is to find a comfortable and stylish shoe that enhances your overall look and can withstand various activities.
STOP WEARING BOAT SHOES
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between docksiders and topsiders?
Docksiders and topsiders are both types of boat shoes that have similar features and are often used interchangeably. The main difference lies in the brand names. Docksiders is a brand of boat shoe manufactured by Sebago, while topsiders is a brand of boat shoe produced by Sperry. Functionally, both shoes are designed for use on boats and provide excellent grip on wet surfaces. However, some users may find slight differences in comfort and fit between the two brands due to variations in design and materials used.
Are docksiders and topsiders waterproof?
Both docksiders and topsiders are made from high-quality leather or canvas materials that are treated to be water-resistant. This means they can withstand light splashes and brief exposure to water without getting soaked. However, it’s important to note that they are not completely waterproof. If fully submerged or exposed to heavy rains, they may absorb water and take some time to dry. It is recommended to treat them with water-repellent sprays or conditioners regularly to maintain their water-resistance.
Which brand offers better durability, docksiders or topsiders?
Both docksiders and topsiders are renowned for their durability. The longevity of a boat shoe depends on various factors such as usage, maintenance, and materials used. While docksiders by Sebago are known for their handcrafted construction and use of high-quality materials, topsiders by Sperry are also recognized for their well-made design. Ultimately, the durability of the shoe will depend on individual usage and care. Regular cleaning, proper storage, and periodic maintenance can help extend the lifespan of any boat shoe.
Can docksiders and topsiders be worn as everyday shoes?
Absolutely! Docksiders and topsiders are versatile shoes and can be worn not only on boats but also as everyday casual footwear. Their timeless design and comfortable features make them suitable for various occasions and outfits. Whether you’re going for a walk, attending a casual event, or simply running errands, both docksiders and topsiders can add style and practicality to your everyday look.
Which shoe brand offers better arch support, docksiders or topsiders?
Both docksiders and topsiders offer decent arch support, but some individuals may find one brand more comfortable than the other depending on their foot shape and preferences. It’s recommended to try on both brands and see which one provides a better fit and support for your feet. Additionally, using orthotic inserts can enhance the arch support of any boat shoe if needed.
Can docksiders and topsiders be resoled?
Yes, both docksiders and topsiders can be resoled. Due to their durable construction, these boat shoes can often withstand multiple sole replacements, extending their overall lifespan. It is advised to take them to a professional cobbler who has experience working with boat shoes to ensure proper resoling. This way, you can continue to enjoy your favorite pair of docksiders or topsiders for years to come.
Final Thoughts
Docksiders and Topsiders are both popular choices for comfortable and stylish footwear. While Docksiders offer a classic and rugged appeal, Topsiders provide a more polished and refined look. Both options excel in terms of durability and versatility, with sturdy construction and slip-resistant soles. Ultimately, the choice between Docksiders and Topsiders boils down to personal preference and style. Whether you’re a fan of the traditional boat shoe or prefer a sleeker design, both options offer quality and comfort. So, whether you’re hitting the docks or heading out for a casual day out, docksiders vs topsiders, there’s a perfect shoe for every occasion.
